SPRAY NOZZLE SELECTION FOR BAND APPLICATIONS

Alan Dexter
Sugarbeet Weed Control Specialist

The designation on the teejet nozzles has a specific meaning. The first two numbers indicate the spray angle. An 8001 nozzle has an 80 degree spray angle at 40 psi. The second two numbers indicate the capacity of the nozzle. An 8001 nozzle would deliver 0.1 gallons per minute (gpm) of water at 40 pounds per square inch pressure (psi). The E following the numbers means that the nozzle is an even spray nozzle and can be used for banding. The Delavan nozzle that is equivalent to the 8001E Teejet nozzle is the LE-1 80°. The LE-1 80° is an even spray nozzle with 0.1 8 pm capacity and 80° spray angle at 40 psi. The Delavan LF-1 25° listed in the table is a flat spray nozzle and flat spray nozzles should not normally be used for banding. However, when the spray angle of a Delavan nozzle is as narrow as 25 degrees, then the spray pattern approaches an even spray nozzle and therefore can be used for banding. The narrow angle nozzles must be positioned quite high for a 5 inch band and the spray particles would be more susceptible to drift. The Spraying Systems TZ and the Delavan HC nozzles are hollow cone nozzles. The HC-6 45° and the TZ-6 nozzles will deliver 6 gallons per hour (gph). The HC-6 45° nozzle has a 45° spray angle and the TZ-6 has a 50° spray angle at 40 psi. Please note that the number on the hollow cone nozzles indicate gallons per hour and the number on the flat fan nozzles indicate gallons per minute. Thus the HC-6 and TZ-6 nozzles have the same delivery as the 8001E, LE-1 80°, or 4001E nozzles.

Spraying Systems recently developed a narrow angle flat fan even spray nozzle for band application. The example in the table is the 4001E. This nozzle has a 40° spray angle and delivers 0.1 8pm at 40 psi.

Double nozzle sprayers
Band sprayers with two nozzles per row are currently available. The two nozzles generally spray towards one another at approximately 45° from vertical. The nozzles are arranged over the row rather than at the sides of the row.

Hollow cone nozzles in a vertical position can be used for band application because they produce a spray pattern that is fairly uniform from edge to edge. However, when a hollow cone nozzle is angled from vertical, the spray pattern becomes heavy in the center and light at the edges. Hollow cone nozzles should not be used in the double nozzle band sprayers since two hollow cone nozzles turned at a 45° angle from vertical produce a spray pattern which is not uniform from edge to edge. Two angled flat fan band application nozzles (Table 1) produce a more uniform pattern than two angled hollow cone nozzles in the double nozzle sprayers.

Table 2 and Table 3 do not contain all the possible nozzle sizes, spray pressures, band widths, row widths, and operating speeds. The following formulas and examples may be useful in obtaining answers for situations not covered in Table 2 and Table 3.

Desired nozzle size

One formula to calculate the desired nozzle size for band application follows:

43,560 sq ft/A
band width in feet
= linear feet of row
in an acre
feet of row/A
5280 ft/mile
= miles of row/A
miles of row/A
speed in mph
= hours to cover
1 acre
desired gallons per acre in the band
hours to cover 1 acre
= desired nozzle capacity in gallons per hour. Divide by 60 to change to gallons per minute.

Example:

Assume 5
4
40
20
inch band
mph
psi
gpa in the band.
43560
5/12
= 104,544 ft/A
104,544
5280
= 19,8 miles/A
19.8
4 mph
= 4.95 hrs/A
20 gpa
4.95
= 4 gph nozzle capacity

Different Speeds: The delivery rate in gallons per acre is indirectly proportional to the speed that the sprayer travels.

Height for a desired band width

The height of a nozzle for a desired band width can be calculated using the formula

Tangent of the angle = side opposite
side adjacent

Example: How high should a 45° nozzle be set to obtain a 6 inch band width?

Tangent 22.5 = 3 inches (side opposite)
unknown height (side adjacent)
.414 = 3
X
X = X = 7.2 inches. Nozzle height for a 6 inch band with a 45° nozzle.

The tangent of angles can be found in tables of Trigometric Functions which are common in math books, in the Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, or is often on electronic calculators.

The height of a nozzle for a desired band width can also be determined by using a protractor. Using a protractor, draw an angle which equals the nozzle angle at the top of a sheet of paper. Use a ruler to determine the distance from the point of the angle to the point where the width between the sides of the angle equals the desired band width. The distance from the desired width to the point of the angle will equal the height of the nozzle above the target. Remember that nozzle angles are rated at 40 psi. A higher pressure will produce a wider angle and a lower pressure will produce a narrower angle.

Different nozzles
Other unlisted nozzles with the same nozzle capacity as nozzles listed in the table will deliver the same gallons per acre if all other conditions are kept the same. However, the spray angle may be different and the nozzle height would then need to be adjusted to get a 5 or 7 inch band. Delivery rate is directly proportional to gallons per acre delivered so delivery rate from nozzle sizes not listed can be calculated.

Example: If a nozzle which delivers 4 gal/hr applies 25 gallons/A, how much would a nozzle that delivers 6 gal/hr apply?

4 gal/hr
6 gal/hr
= gal/A with 4 gal/hr nozzle
gal/A with 6 gal/hr nozzle
4
6
= 25
X
4X = 150
x = 37.5 gal/A with 6 gal/hr nozzle

Different spray pressures: The following formula will give an estimate of the change in delivery rate for a change in pressure.

Rate in gal/A a high pressure =

sq. rt. high pressure
low pressure

x rate at low pressure

Example: If a sprayer delivers 40 gal/A at 60 psi, how much would be delivered at 30 psi?

40 gal/A = sq. rt. 60
30
= low rate at pressure
40 gal/A = sq. rt. 2 = low rate
40 gal/A = 1.4 = low rate
40
1.4
= 28.6 gal/A at 30 psi

Different band widths: The delivery rate in gallons per treated acre isin directly proportional to band width.

Example: If a sprayer delivers 20 gallons per treated acre in a 7 inch band, how much would be delivered in a 4 inch band?

7 inch band
4 inch band
= gal/A in 4 inch band
gal/A in 7 inch band
7
4
= x
20
4X = 140
x = 35 gallons per treated acre in a 4 inch band.

Different speeds: The delivery rate in gallons per acre is indirectly proportional to the speed that the sprayer travels.

Example: If a sprayer delivers 30 gallons per acre at 7 mph, how much would be delivered at 10 mph?

7 mph
10 mph
= gal/A at 10 mph
gal/A at 7 mph
7
10
= X
30
10X = 210
X = 21 gal/A at 10 mph

The data in Tables 2 and 3 should be confirmed by a field calibration. The data in the Table should be close enough to assist in nozzle selection and to confirm that the calculations from a field calibration are in the right range.Since variation in speedometers, variation in pressure gauges, and nozzle wear greatly affect the gallons per acre delivered by a sprayer, a sprayer cannot safely be calibrated by calculations. A field check on delivery rate must be made. The following section gives some possible methods for calibration.

Ground sprayer calibration:
The procedure for calibrating a sprayer should not be difficult. Calibration is simply measuring the volume delivered by the sprayer to a small part of an acre and then calculating how much would be delivered to the entire acre.

The first step in any calibration procedure is to check the flow rate of all nozzles on the sprayer. Any nozzles that are abnormal in delivery rate should be cleaned or if cleaning does not correct the problem, replaced.

Three possible methods of calibrating a sprayer after checking nozzle delivery rate follow:

Method 1.

a) measure out 660 feet in the field to be sprayed.
b) fill spray tank up into the neck with water and mark the level of the water.
c) spray over the 660 feet at the sprayer pressure and speed to be used for the field.
d) record the volume necessary to refill the spray tank to the level marked in step e) calculate the amount of water applied per acre by using the following formula.

gallons per acre = gallons sprayed over the 660 ft x 66
width actually treated by sprayer in ft

f) the width treated by the sprayer would be the boom width for a broadcast application. For banding, width would be band width in feet x number of bands and the gallonage would be gallons per treated acre.

Method 2.

a) measure out 660 feet in the field to be sprayed.
b) drive over the 660 feet with the sprayer but without spraying. Record the time required to travel the 660 feet at the speed which will be used for the field.
c) with a stationary sprayer, catch the volume of water delivered from 2 to 4 nozzles in the length of time it took to travel over the 660 feet. Use the sprayer pressure which will be used in the field.
d) record the volume caught from the nozzles and calculate how much would have been delivered from all nozzles using the following formula:

gallons applied over 660 feet = gallons caught X number of nozzles on sprayer
number of nozzles from which spray was caught.

e) calculate the amount of water applied per acre by using the following formula:

gallons per acre = gallons applied over 660 ft. x 66
width actually treated by the sprayer in ft.

f) the width treated by the sprayer would be the boom width for a broadcast application. For banding, width would be band width in feet x number of bands and the gallonage would be gallons per treated acre.

Method 3.

a) if some distance other than 660 feet would be easier to use, then methods 1 and 2 can be used with a different distance but the formula for calculating gallons per acre must be modified as follows:

gallons per acre = gallons sprayed in test run
width treated by the sprayer in ft.
x
x
43560 sq. ft. in an acre
length of test run in ft.

This method will give gallons per treated acre for a band sprayer.

b) at least 300 feet should be used for a test run.

Sample Calibration Problems
Problem 1: 9 gallons of water were used by a 12-row band sprayer in a half mile test run spraying a seven inch band in 22-inch rows. How much Betanex should be put in 150 gallons of water in the spray tank to apply 1 lb/A active ingredient or 6.1 pints of product per treated acre (broadcast rate). Betanex at 1 lb/A or 6.15 pints per treated acre is equivalent to 0.32 lb/A or 2 pints per total acre (band rate).

- Calculations -

Method 1:

Actual acres treated in 1/2 mile test run = 2640 ft/1/2 mile x 12 rows x 7/12 ft. band
43,560 sq ft/acre
= 0.424 acres
gallons per treated acre = 9 gal in test run
.424 treated acres in test run
= 21.2 gal/treated acre

Want to apply 6.15 pints per actual treated acre so every 21.2 gallons of spray solution should contain 6.15 pints of Betanex.

Betanex per 150 gallons = 150
21.2
x 6.15 = 43.5 pints of Betanex per 150 total gallons of spray solution.

At 21.2 gal/treated acre, 150 gallons will treat 7.1 acres. Only 7/22 of the soil is being treated so the total field acres covered while treating 7.1 acres would be 7.1 x 22/7 = 22.3 total acres.

Method 2:

Another way to calculate the same problem would be to use the band rate and the total acres instead of the broadcast rate and the treated acres.

total acres in
1/2 mile test run
= 2640 ft/1/2 mile x 12 rows x 22/12 ft/row
43,560 sq ft/acre
= 1.333 acres
gallons per total acre = 9 gal in test run
1.3 total acres in test run
= 6.9 gal/total acre

Want to apply 2 pints per total acre (band rate) so every 6.9 gallons of spray solution should contain 2 pints of Betanex.

Betanex per 150 gallons = 150
6.9
x 2 = 43.5 pints of Betanex per 150 total gallons of spray solution.

This is the same answer as derived from method 1. The 150 gallons will still cover 7.1 treated acres or 22.3 total acres.

Problem 2: A sprayer has a tank which will hold 250 gallons. Betanex is to be applied in a 5 inch band on 22 inch rows at seven miles per hour and 40psi. The desired delivery rate is 20 gallons per treated acre. What size nozzle should be used? How much water should be used by a 12 row band sprayer in a 1/2 mile test run? Assuming the actual test run uses the same amount of water as calculated, how much Betanex would be put in the 250 gallon tank for1 lb/A or 6.15 pints per acre broadcast rate.

- Calculations

Look in Table 2 and find that-at 7 mph and 40 psi that a nozzle with a delivery rate of 8 gallons/hour will apply 22.6 gallons per treated acre or 5.1 gallons per total acre with a 5 inch band and 22 inch rows at 7 mph. The 22.6 gal/A rate is close enough to the desired 20 gal/A.

Method 1:

Acres actually treated in a 1/2 mile test run = 2640 ft/1/2 mile x 12 rows x 5/12 ft band
43,560 sq ft/acre
= 0.303 acres
Gallons expected to be used in 1/2 mile test run = 22.6 gal/treated acre x 0.303 = 1.33 acres

Method 2:

Total acres in a 1/2 mile test run = 2640 ft/1/2 mile x 12 rows x 22/12 ft/row
43,560 sq ft/acre
= 1.33 acres
Gallons expected to be used in 1/2 mile test run = 5.1 gal/total acre x 1.33 = 6.8 gal.

Method 1:

Betanex per 250 gallons = 250 gal/tank
22.6 gal/treated acre
x 6.15 pts/ treated acre = 68.0 pints/250 gal

The band rate of Betanex or the amount to apply per total acre with 5 inch bands and 22 inch rows would be 6.15 pts/treated acre x 5/22 = 1.4 pints/total acre.

Betanex per 250 gallons = 250 gal/tank
5.14 gal/total acre
x 1.4 pints/ total acre = 68.1 pints/ 250 gal.

The same answer (within rounding error) was obtained with both methods.


1978 Sugarbeet Research and Education Board, Volume 9, pg. 48 -58


Questions/Comments