Table 19 (2 pages)
2002 Aphanomyces Readings for Coded Test Entries
Betaseed Nursery - Shakopee, MN
2002 Ratings Approval + Disapproval ++
Foliar * Root Index** 2 Yr Mean 3 Yr Mean 2001 2001 2000 2000
Code Description Rating % App+ Rating % App+ Foliar* %App+ Rt.Indx** %App+ Foliar* %App++ Rt.Indx** %App++ Foliar* Rt.Indx** Foliar* Rt.Indx**
616 Beta 2088 4.17 116 6.33 121 4.38 127.5 6.42 121.3 4.47 128.3 6.28 112.7 4.58 6.50 4.67 6.00
723 Beta 3777(Aph) 3.08 86 5.00 96 3.29 95.9 5.25 99.2 3.30 94.8 5.11 91.7 3.50 5.50 3.33 4.83
655 Beta 3800(Aph) 3.00 84 4.50 86 3.09 89.9 4.59 86.7 2.89 82.9 4.39 78.8 3.17 4.67 2.50 4.00
688 Beta 3820(Aph) 3.42 95 4.67 90 3.42 99.7 4.92 93.0 3.22 92.5 4.81 86.4 3.42 5.17 2.83 4.60
717 Beta 3861(BX0961 Aph Spec) 2.75 77 4.50 86 3.21 93.6 4.92 92.9 2.70 77.4 4.61 82.8 3.67 5.33 1.67 4.00
  644 Beta 4811(Aph & Rzm) 3.25 91 4.50 86 3.04 88.6 4.09 77.2 2.80 80.4 3.89 69.8 2.83 3.67 2.33 3.50
703 Beta 4818R(M813 Aph & Rzm) 3.17 88 4.67 90 3.17 92.4 4.42 83.6 3.00 86.2 4.39 78.8 3.17 4.17 2.67 4.33
650 Beta 6225(X925) 3.42 95 5.33 102 3.71 108.1 5.83 110.2 4.00 6.33
712 Beta 6233(BX0933) 3.25 91 5.00 96 3.46 100.9 5.50 104.0 3.67 6.00
659 Beta 6400 3.25 91 4.83 93 3.04 88.6 4.75 89.8 2.97 85.2 4.72 84.8 2.83 4.67 2.83 4.67
709 Beta 6447 3.92 109 6.17 118 3.46 100.9 5.42 102.5 3.47 99.6 5.45 97.8 3.00 4.67 3.50 5.50
  604 Beta 6600 3.75 105 5.67 109 4.00 116.6 5.75 108.7 4.06 116.4 5.72 102.8 4.25 5.83 4.17 5.67
615 Beta 6610(X926) 3.33 93 5.00 96 3.75 109.3 5.42 102.4 4.17 5.83
722 Beta 6663(BX0963) 3.75 105 5.33 102 3.88 113.0 5.50 104.0 4.00 5.67
675 Beta 991RR(Aph) 3.25 91 5.33 102 3.29 95.9 5.50 104.0 3.30 94.8 5.39 96.8 3.33 5.67 3.33 5.17
671 Beta 993RR(Rzm) 3.42 95 5.17 99
625 Beta BX1001(6301) 3.83 107 5.67 109
  694 Beta BX1024 3.50 98 5.17 99 3.50 102.0 5.42 102.5         3.50 5.67    
661 Beta BX1101 3.25 91 4.50 86
645 Beta BX1103 3.58 100 5.00 96
670 Beta BX1104 3.58 100 5.33 102
700 Beta BX1105(Rzm) 4.58 128 5.67 109
624 Beta BX1106(Rzm) 4.33 121 6.33 121
  651 Beta BX1107(Rzm) 4.42 123 6.33 121                        
634 Beta BX1108(Rzm) 3.83 107 5.17 99
690 Beta BX1191 3.50 98 5.33 102
708 Beta BX1192 3.92 109 5.33 102
602 Beta BX1193 4.00 112 5.67 109
695 Beta BX1194 3.25 91 5.17 99
  664 Beta BX1195(Rzm) 3.58 100 5.33 102                        
631 Beta BX1196(Rzm) 4.17 116 6.33 121
653 Beta BX1197(Rzm) 3.17 88 4.67 90
668 Beta BX1198(Rzm) 4.00 112 5.50 106
660 Croplan CL101 4.08 114 6.00 115 4.04 117.8 5.75 108.7 3.86 110.7 5.44 97.7 4.00 5.50 3.50 4.83
614 Croplan CL102 4.08 114 5.67 109 4.08 118.9 5.50 104.0 4.22 121.1 5.44 97.7 4.08 5.33 4.50 5.33
  680 Crystal 723 3.58 100 5.17 99                        
606 Crystal 725 3.17 88 4.67 90 3.25 94.7 4.92 93.0 3.33 5.17
705 Crystal 817 4.42 123 6.33 121 4.63 134.8 6.33 119.7 4.64 133.1 6.16 110.7 4.83 6.33 4.67 5.83
711 Crystal 820(Aph) 3.25 91 4.83 93 3.04 88.6 4.75 89.8 2.92 83.7 4.61 82.8 2.83 4.67 2.67 4.33
632 Crystal 822(Aph) 2.92 81 4.67 90 2.84 82.6 4.75 89.8 2.61 75.0 4.67 83.8 2.75 4.83 2.17 4.50
683 Crystal 830RR(Aph) 3.00 84 4.00 77 3.17 92.3 4.42 83.5 3.33 4.83
  641 Crystal 952(Aph) 3.25 91 4.67 90 2.96 86.3 4.75 89.8 2.81 80.5 4.67 83.8 2.67 4.83 2.50 4.50
656 Crystal 955 4.42 123 6.33 121 4.42 128.8 6.17 116.5 4.42 6.00
691 Crystal 956(Aph) 3.08 86 4.67 90 3.42 99.5 5.00 94.5 3.22 92.4 4.72 84.8 3.75 5.33 2.83 4.17
603 Crystal 957 4.00 112 5.33 102 3.79 110.5 5.50 104.0 3.58 5.67
718 Crystal 999 3.42 95 5.17 99 3.34 97.2 5.09 96.1 3.17 90.8 4.78 85.8 3.25 5.00 2.83 4.17
626 Crystal AX201(Aph) 3.33 93 4.67 90
  702 Crystal R270(Rzm & Aph) 3.25 91 4.33 83                        
622 Crystal R826(Rzm) 3.08 86 4.50 86 3.21 93.4 5.00 94.5 3.33 5.50
713 Crystal R932(Rzm & Aph) 3.17 88 4.17 80 3.17 4.83
646 Crystal RX207(Rzm) 3.08 86 4.17 80
720 Crystal RX208(Rzm) 3.17 88 4.17 80
639 Crystal RX209(Rzm) 4.00 112 5.67 109
  684 Crystal X210RR 3.33 93 5.00 96                        
649 Hilleshog 129RzRR (Rzm) 3.08 86 5.67 109 4.00 6.00
677 Hilleshog 131RzRR (Rzm) 3.92 109 6.33 121
610 Hilleshog 132RzRR (Rzm) 3.92 109 6.83 131
672 Hilleshog 2093(7093) 4.08 114 6.67 128 4.38 127.5 6.42 121.4 4.36 125.1 6.22 111.7 4.67 6.17 4.33 5.83
698 Hilleshog 2195(7095) 3.92 109 6.17 118 4.13 120.2 6.00 113.4 3.81 109.2 5.67 101.7 4.33 5.83 3.17 5.00
  629 Hilleshog 2236(7136 Aph) 2.50 70 4.33 83 2.75 80.2 4.42 83.5         3.00 4.50    
685 Hilleshog 2239(7139 Aph) 2.67 75 4.33 83 2.71 79.0 4.58 86.6 2.75 4.83
667 Hilleshog 2411Rz(7111 Rzm) 3.75 105 5.17 99 4.00 5.17
611 Hilleshog 2433Rz(7133 Rzm) 3.92 109 5.17 99 3.88 113.0 5.09 96.1 3.83 5.00
640 Hilleshog 2447Rz(Rzm) 3.83 107 6.67 128
676 Hilleshog 7054 3.83 107 5.17 99 4.08 118.9 5.17 97.7 4.33 5.17
  636 Hilleshog 7078 4.08 114 6.50 125 4.42 128.7 6.50 122.9         4.75 6.50    
654 Hilleshog 7089(Aph) 4.08 114 6.17 118 4.17 121.4 6.25 118.1 4.17 119.5 5.89 105.7 4.25 6.33 4.17 5.17
665 Hilleshog 7163Rz(Rzm) 2.75 77 3.83 73
609 Hilleshog 7164(Aph) 2.58 72 4.17 80
710 Hilleshog 7166Rz(Rzm) 4.17 116 5.83 112
693 Hilleshog 7167Rz(Rzm) 3.83 107 5.83 112
  618 Hilleshog 7168Rz(Rzm) 4.50 126 7.50 144                        
687 Hilleshog 7169Rz(Rzm & Aph) 2.92 81 4.50 86
658 Hilleshog 7171Rz(Rzm) 4.25 119 6.83 131
701 Hilleshog 7172Rz(Rzm & Rhc) 3.42 95 4.50 86
635 Hilleshog 7173 5.00 140 7.83 150
692 Hilleshog 7175Rz(Rzm) 3.58 100 5.00 96
  605 Hilleshog 7176Rz(Rzm) 3.67 102 5.17 99                        
663 Hilleshog Blazer 4.08 114 5.83 112 4.29 125.1 6.00 113.4 3.86 110.7 5.67 101.7 4.50 6.17 3.00 5.00
716 Hilleshog Horizon 3.58 100 5.50 106 3.96 115.3 5.75 108.7 3.69 106.0 5.56 99.8 4.33 6.00 3.17 5.17
628 Hilleshog Resist(Aph) 3.25 91 4.83 93 2.71 79.0 4.25 80.3 2.53 72.6 4.33 77.8 2.17 3.67 2.17 4.50
706 Holly 00HX016 4.00 112 6.17 118
652 Holly 00HX017 3.83 107 6.17 118
  699 Holly 02HX253(Aph & Rzm) 3.33 93 4.33 83                        
608 Holly 02HX254(Rzm Spec) 3.00 84 4.50 86
617 Holly HH-112 3.83 107 5.33 102 4.04 117.8 5.58 105.5 3.86 110.7 5.39 96.7 4.25 5.83 3.50 5.00
681 Holly HH-114 3.83 107 4.83 93 4.00 116.6 5.25 99.2 4.00 114.8 5.28 94.7 4.17 5.67 4.00 5.33
643 Holly HH-115 3.75 105 5.33 102 4.04 117.8 5.75 108.7 3.92 112.4 5.56 99.8 4.33 6.17 3.67 5.17
678 Holly HH-811 3.83 107 5.33 102 4.08 118.9 5.58 105.5 4.22 121.1 5.55 99.7 4.33 5.83 4.50 5.50
  623 Holly HH-931(99HX931) 4.00 112 5.67 109 3.92 114.1 5.50 104.0         3.83 5.33    
669 Seedex Gladiator 3.33 93 5.67 109 3.71 108.0 5.75 108.7 4.03 115.5 5.78 103.7 4.08 5.83 4.67 5.83
704 Seedex Monarch 3.83 107 5.50 106 3.83 111.6 5.50 104.0 4.00 114.7 5.56 99.8 3.83 5.50 4.33 5.67
619 Seedex Prompt(Aph&Rhc) 3.17 88 4.67 90 2.96 86.3 4.75 89.8 2.97 85.3 4.78 85.8 2.75 4.83 3.00 4.83
666 Seedex SX0816 3.83 107 6.00 115
721 Seedex SX0822(Aph) 3.25 91 4.67 90 3.54 103.2 5.09 96.1 3.83 5.50
  612 Seedex SX0823(Aph) 3.17 88 4.83 93 3.00 87.5 4.75 89.8         2.83 4.67    
707 Seedex SX0827(Aph & Rzm) 3.58 100 4.83 93
633 Seedex SX0828(Aph & Rzm) 3.33 93 5.83 112
696 Seedex SX0829(Aph & Rhc) 3.08 86 4.50 86
621 Seedex SX0917(Aph) 3.75 105 5.00 96
689 Seedex SX0924(Aph) 3.08 86 4.33 83 3.17 92.3 4.42 83.5 3.25 4.50
  642 Seedex SX0925(Aph) 3.33 93 4.83 93 3.25 94.7 4.83 91.3         3.17 4.83    
715 Seedex SX0927(Aph & Rzm) 4.00 112 4.67 90
627 Seedex SX0928(Aph & Rzm) 3.33 93 5.50 106
674 Seedex SX0929(Aph) 3.83 107 5.50 106
719 Seedex Thunder 3.58 100 5.33 102 3.88 113.0 5.67 107.1 3.97 114.0 5.61 100.7 4.17 6.00 4.17 5.50
647 Seedex Titan 3.67 102 6.17 118 3.88 113.0 6.09 115.0 3.92 112.4 6.06 108.7 4.08 6.00 4.00 6.00
  682 Van der Have H46140(Aph) 3.08 86 4.17 80 3.08 89.8 4.84 91.4 2.89 82.8 4.61 82.8 3.08 5.50 2.50 4.17
637 Van der Have H46177(Aph & Rzm) 3.08 86 4.33 83 2.96 86.1 4.33 81.9 2.64 75.6 4.22 75.8 2.83 4.33 2.00 4.00
662 Van der Have H46515(Aph & Rzm) 3.25 91 4.50 86
601 Van der Have H46516(Aph & Rzm) 3.33 93 4.50 86
657 Van der Have H46517(Aph & Rzm) 4.33 121 6.00 115
673 Van der Have H46521(Aph & Rhc) 3.58 100 5.17 99
  638 Van der Have H66156 3.92 109 6.00 115 3.92 114.3 5.92 111.8 4.17 119.6 5.89 105.7 3.92 5.83 4.67 5.83
613 Van der Have H66240 3.58 100 5.17 99 3.71 108.0 5.17 97.7 3.75 107.5 5.17 92.8 3.83 5.17 3.83 5.17
686 Van der Have H66283 4.08 114 5.67 109 3.79 110.5 5.59 105.6 3.86 110.7 5.50 98.7 3.50 5.50 4.00 5.33
630 Van der Have H66335 4.25 119 5.67 109 4.25 123.9 5.75 108.7 4.17 119.5 5.56 99.8 4.25 5.83 4.00 5.17
697 Van der Have H66453 4.08 114 6.00 115 4.13 120.2 6.09 115.0 4.17 6.17
620 Van der Have H66556 3.92 109 5.17 99
  679 Van der Have H66557 3.67 102 5.33 102                        
607 Van der Have H66561 3.92 109 5.83 112
714 Van der Have H66725(Aph) 3.25 91 5.50 106
648 Van der Have H85001RR 3.25 91 5.17 99 3.59 104.5 5.34 100.9 3.92 5.50
724 Beta 3800(Chk) 2.75 77 4.17 80 2.960 86.3 4.42 83.6 2.807 80.5 4.28 76.8 3.17 4.67 2.50 4.00
725 Crystal 960(Chk) 2.83 79 4.33 83 2.705 78.9 4.42 83.5 2.470 70.9 4.28 76.8 2.58 4.50 2.00 4.00
  726 Crystal 999(Chk) 3.50 98 5.00 96 3.375 98.4 5.00 94.5 3.193 91.6 4.72 84.8 3.25 5.00 2.83 4.17
727 Hilleshog Resist(Chk) 3.50 98 4.83 93 2.835 82.6 4.25 80.3 2.613 75.0 4.33 77.8 2.17 3.67 2.17 4.50
728 Van der Have H46140(Chk) 3.00 84 4.33 83 3.040 88.6 4.92 92.9 2.860 82.0 4.67 83.8 3.08 5.50 2.50 4.17
729 Crystal 960 Tach Pellet 2.25 63 4.33 83
730 Aph Tolerant Hybrid 3.00 84 4.33 83 3.06 89.3 4.42 83.5 3.13 4.50
731 Aph Tolerant Source 3.25 91 5.00 96 3.38 98.4 5.29 100.0 3.50 5.59
  732 Aph Susceptible Hybrid (AST) 4.67 130 7.83 150 5.32 154.9 7.67 144.9         5.96 7.50    
733 Aph Mod Susc 4.25 119 6.33 121 4.56 133.0 6.54 123.6 4.88 6.75
734 Aph Tolerant Hybrid 2.92 81 4.33 83 3.02 88.1 4.42 83.5 3.13 4.50
735 Aph Tolerant Source 3.08 86 4.83 93 3.29 95.9 5.21 98.4 3.50 5.59
736 Aph Susceptible Hybrid (AST) 5.08 142 7.83 150 5.52 160.9 7.67 144.9 5.96 7.50
  737 Aph Mod Susc 4.08 114 6.33 121 4.48 130.5 6.54 123.6         4.88 6.75    
              Check Mean                          3.12 4.53 2.983 4.60 2.789 4.46 2.85 4.67 2.40 4.17
              Coeff. of Var. (%)                  11.97 11.19
LSD .05 0.49 0.67
LSD .01 0.64 0.88
Check Mean * 115% (Approval Criteria) 3.58 5.21 3.430 5.29 3.21 5.12 3.28 5.37 2.76 4.79
Check Mean * 125% (Disapproval Criteria) 3.90   5.67   3.73   5.75   3.486   5.57   3.56 5.84 3.00 5.21
+ Approval is based upon the two year foliar rating and other comparisons are for general information.
++ Disapproval is based upon the three year foliar rating and other comparisons are for general information (approval policy change 1-14-02).
Check varieties are Beta 3800, Crystal 960, Crystal 999, Hilleshog Resist & van der Have H46140 (entries 724 to 728).
* Foliar rating is the Aph Foliar 2 rating (7/12 & 8/2 mean) from the unidentified data.
** Root rating of Aph symptoms was done on 10/1 (1=healthy, 9=severe damage).